Page 144
By Jack Joseph Smith
By Jack Joseph Smith
Original Scan
AI Interpretation
Seeing O'Dandy's crowd as ugly and distorted once he is sober, the narrator watches his Sunday picnic erupt when a huge man named Thomas is called a monster, and he steps into the trouble to protect both his patrons and his rough little enterprise.
The scene keeps the loose, boozy carnival of the picnic but strips the glamour from the old crowd by making them look swollen, hateful, and absurd. Money, reputation, and the need to manage the crowd matter just as much as courage, so the fight begins already tangled in business and performance.
Sober, the narrator finds O'Dandy's crowd ugly, their faces 'bulky and distorted, somewhat like Dolveskey characters', until Young Ben runs in shouting about a monster who tossed him 'twenty feet in the air'; following to protect his patrons, the narrator faces 'a huge negro man' of 'three hundred and fifty pounds', dodges an arm 'like a huge treee branch', hits him 'right in the nose', and watches the fallen man, Thomas, begin to pound an unlucky college boy.
The page mixes comic exaggeration with real menace, and the narrator admits his courage is also business, since he 'didn't want to lose any drinkers'. The racial framing of the 'monster' is part of the crowd's panic that the prose both reports and partly shares.