Toy
By Jack Joseph Smith
By Jack Joseph Smith
Original Scan
AI Interpretation
An uneasy encounter poem in which desire, pity, and damage are inseparable, making intimacy feel exposed and ethically unstable.
The speaker begins by naming Toy's injuries and personal desire, then describes the sex as bottomless and empty "for my second time", without defining the scope of that count. The speaker recalls her beauty and sorrow, being sick, and worrying while hearing her in the bathroom. The speaker hears about the fire and says yes to the prospect of marriage. The speaker leaves with Toy and sees the crooked lines of her flesh.
'Toy' describes 'The burned baby on the wooden bed / This nineteen year old whore' who covers herself with a 'dark blue quilt', calls the sex 'nothing, bottomless and empty for my second time', and dwells on 'the unusual beauty, the outward strength, / and deep sorrow of her face'. After 'I was sick' and an awkward exchange, she tells him 'about the fire', and the poem ends 'Would I marry her yes as she took off her gown' and 'I left with her, / seeing the crooked lines of her flesh'.
The poem sets a flat, almost reportorial account of a paid encounter against moments of tenderness and unease, and it does not resolve the tension between desire and pity. Handwritten revisions such as 'I was sick' and 'There she was' shift attention to the speaker's own reaction, while the plain typed lines and spellings like 'drapped' and 'devistating' keep a raw, unpolished voice. The marriage line is stated rather than explained, so what the speaker's 'yes' commits to is left open.